This is the
first time we've had a good look at Shamrock, and I'm not sure
whether this example is representative of what they are building
today. However, we do get a lot of questions about this builder
which heretofore we've been unable to answer.
Without further ado, I'll say that this boat
is basically just run-of-the-mill, ho hum, plane jane fiberglass
boat. Aside from the style of the hull and the keel, there are
zillions just like it. At 11 years old it's holding up okay but
has its share of problems.
- The hull sides are extremely thin.
- The transom is plywood cored, is delaminated and rotted.
- The transom is so swollen with water that it has distorted
and buckled and delaminated the cockpit liner.
- The exhaust system uses iron pipe, laying deep in the bilge.
You can guess the outcome.
- The exhaust piping is below the waterline, which is real
helpful to the engine exhaust valves.
- The cockpit drains are an inch above the water line and
it looks like this boat has sunk at least once because of
it.
- The bottom is badly blistered.
- The engine transmission is deep in the bilge and gets wet
with about two inches of water in the bilge, which is
then thrown around by the shaft coupling. The engine was rebuilt
one year ago, but has already turned into a ball of rust.
Other than that, everything is fine. But, hey,
no boat is perfect. You can fix all those things. At least once.
With a single 270 hp V8 gas inboard with the
builders trade name on it, and a relatively flat bottom, this
boat is a flyer in calm water, but the seas on this day were a
bit too much for this size boat to try it out in the ocean. Looking
at the bottom, I'd consider it basically a fair weather sailor.
The boat has trim tabs but doesn't need them since it trims out
very flat.
|
There's no mystery about what might
cause this boat to sink with the scuppers 1" above water
line and the deck with hatch opening only 3' above water line.
Of course, you're supposed to put the plugs in the drains
. . . . . |
| 
|
The engine spark plugs
are below deck level. Good luck getting them out. Note that
there is no coffer dam around the engine box to keep water
off of iron and steel stuff that rusts. Check out the next
photo. |
The keel, of course, greatly affects the steering
but not adversely. It does not slide into a turn but makes perfectly
level turns which is kinda interesting and fun to zig-zag around.
Really different than what you're used to.
A decent size cuddy cabin is almost useable for
sleep overs, but the enclosed head with a porta potty is best for
what it is currently being used for: storage. No way could I get
my body in there.
 |
 |
| The buyer had been told that the engine
had just been rebuilt, and was given invoices to prove it.
This is what the back and underside of the engine looked like
as a result of the way it was mounted. Rebuilt? In fact, the
seller got screwed by the "rebuilder" who did not
rebuild it. These bolts have never been touched. |
Iron sections of exhaust
system sitting deep in the bilge. |
The motor box is one of the nicest features; it's
set up with fore-n-aft seats that are nice to sit on without getting
much in the way of the cockpit if you're a fishinfanatic. The batteries
are cleverly installed on a frame above the engine and very easy
to service. On the way down side, the engine is installed so deep
in the bilge that the spark plugs are one inch from the deck with
virtually no way to get them out short of lifting the engine. Speaking
of clever, that's not.
All I feel inclined to say is: Nice try but no
cigar.
| These
are "reviews", not surveys, and bear no resemblance
to our survey reports.
We do not publish the results of the surveys that we perform.
Please note that the purpose of these reviews is educational,
to help you discern the differences in quality among boats generally.
They are not offered as a means to help you evaluate any particular
boat builder. We have no other reviews than those posted. |
Posted June 27, 1999
|