"Mid Size Power Boats": A Guide for Discreminating Buyers - by David Pascoe


Diesel Engines


Report on Aluminum Cooling System  Component Failures


Two years ago, in response to a question about the longevity of Yanmar diesel engines, I wrote that I had serious reservations about the extensive use of cast aluminum components on those engines. Up to that time, we hadn't heard of any serious problems with the engines, but then, they were fairly new on the market at that time.

I now have the answer, along with documented, photographic evidence of how well those aluminum parts are holding up.

My original doubts were founded on other engine company's attempts to use cast aluminum. First came Johnson & Towers, the remarketers of Detroit Diesels. Some time in the late 1960's they tried using a cast aluminum heat exchanger tank. In those days, aluminum alloys weren't so good, and tank wide spread failures occurred.  Nor did it escape my attention that it was J&T who tried this, and not General Motors. Seems the GM people knew better.

Not to learn from other's mistakes, soon it was Perkins Engine Company who tried aluminum parts. My own father was a victim of this debacle when both the combined heat exchanger/exhaust manifolds on his engines failed. Replacement cost was a whopping cost of $6,000 each!

Next, along came US Marine and their marinization of the Japanese Hino diesel. Same story, a combined aluminum heat exchanger/exhaust manifold casting at an equally horrendous cost to replace.

Not to be outdone, now comes Yanmar with the very same  combined aluminum heat exchanger/exhaust manifold castings. Shown in the photos below are the very predictable results. In this case, both castings on both engines failed at about the same time.


Galvanic corrosion inside heat exchanger tank.

Attempts to patch holes from exterior proved futile.

So what's wrong with using aluminum parts? Dissimilar metals. Here we had three engine companies that tried to brass heat exchanger bundles into an aluminum tank. Brass and aluminum are far apart on the scale of electrical potential of metals. Hence, the aluminum becomes anodic to the brass, just like the zincs you use on your shafts are anodic to stainless steel. It doesn't take long for them to disappear.

Even though the cooling system is filled with an anticorrosive coolant, that is not going to stop galvanic corrosion.

Bottom line: The effort to make diesel engines lighter by using aluminum components for the cooling system isn't going to work. And, of course, these parts didn't finally fail until the engine was long out of warranty, so the boat owner had to foot the bill.

Fortunately, there is a better way to reduce the weight of cast iron tanks. Most other manufacturers are using formed brass plate tanks. Brass tanks, brass tube bundles, no problem. And the cost is a lot less than a  machined casting.

Posted July 10, 2000

TOP
David Pascoe Power Boat Books

Buyers' Guide to Outboard Boats Surveying Fiberglass Power Boats (2E)
David Pascoe - Biography

David Pascoe is a second generation marine surveyor in his family who began his surveying career at age 16 as an apprentice in 1965 as the era of wooden boats was drawing to a close.

Certified by the National Association of Marine Surveyors in 1972, he has conducted over 5,000 pre purchase surveys in addition to having conducted hundreds of boating accident investigations, including fires, sinkings, hull failures and machinery failure analysis.

Over forty years of knowledge and experience are brought to bear in following books. David Pascoe is the author of:

In addition to readers in the United States, boaters and boat industry professionals worldwide from over 70 countries have purchased David Pascoe's books, since introduction of his first book in 2001.

In 2012, David Pascoe has retired from marine surveying business at age 65.

Biography - Long version

David Pascoe's
Power Boat Books

Mid Size Power Boats Mid Size Power Boats
A Guide for Discriminating Buyers
Focuses exclusively cruiser class generally 30-55 feet
With discussions on the pros and cons of each type: Expresses, trawlers, motor yachts, multi purpose types, sportfishermen and sedan cruisers.
Buyers' Guide to Outboard Boats
Selecting and Evaluating New and Used Boats
Dedicated for offshore outboard boats
A hard and realistic look at the marine market place and delves into issues of boat quality and durability that most other marine writers are unwilling to touch.
Surveying Fiberglass Powewr Boats
Surveying Fiberglass Power Boats
2nd Edition
The Art of Pre-Purchase Survey The very first of its kind, this book provides the essentials that every novice needs to know, as well as a wealth of esoteric details.
Marine Investigations
Pleasure crafts investigations to court testimony The first and only book of its kind on the subject of investigating pleasure craft casualties and other issues.
Readers
Worldwide
Over 70 countries
Countries List
Links to Each Chapter Contents with Excerpt at:
David Pascoe Power Boat Books davidpascoe.com

 

HOME > MARINE ENGINES >
Last reviewed September 25, 2016.